Ok, I'm not proud but when my original Playstation 1 quit working I bought a new one, put the broken one in the box and returned it. It worked. I feel bad about it.
I was pissed that my Playstation broke doing what it was supposed to do and was out of warranty. But Toys R Us had to deal with it.
I was also broke and wanted to play my Plastation games. It's weird what being really broke will make someone come up with.
I also have taken shit back that I've been given as gifts that I don't need to random stores. Somebody gave me a $100+ iHome thing back when I didn't even have an iPod. I took it to Best Buy even though I have no idea where they bought it and got store credit. Seem like less of an offense.
I worked in retail for awhile so I know what work plus if you frequent the FatWalet you can exploit the hell out of things.
That's a grey area. Technically, once it's past the store's return policy, it's the manufacturer's problem if it breaks.
For certain items like that, we would do the "restocking fee". Kept people honest. If the product (certain types qualified - I think GPS, computers, and laptops were the only things) was opened, you could exchange it for another product of the same type, or if you wanted all of your money back, you had to pay a restocking fee. If the box had never been opened, you didn't.
It worked pretty well, IMO. The goal was to prevent people from buying a product, opening it up, swapping it with their old, broken one, then returning it for full credit.
There's a whole ton of issues like that. We haven't even gotten started on misprinted prices. Twice, I remember getting price tags (the individual stores get all their sale prices and price tags from corporate) where the price was obviously incorrect. And, the stupid customers always think that if the price is blatantly incorrect, we need to honor it anyway. Like that thing BestBuy had to deal with a few weeks ago, where their $4000 TV was accidentally sold for $9.99 online.
We had like a $1399 plasma TV that was supposed to go on sale for like $1199. But, the monkey typing the prices into the computer in Richmond wasn't paying attention, so the tag we printed and the price in our system was $199.
In that situation, what we did was pull the price tag, and if any customers asked, we told them the TV was out of stock (since it would ring up as $199). We called corporate, and they fixed it, and the new correct tag came out the next day.
Another time, it was this digital camera, like $299 or something accidentally tagged as $9.99. One of our employees got the bright idea to buy a bunch and sell them on ebay, and he told his friends. So about 4-5 of our employees bought like 20 of these cameras to sell on ebay, and once the regional manager found out, they all got fired for internal theft.