jimpeel
Well-Known Member
Is there nothing they will not abrogate from the individual?
I can't donate because of my hepatitis C but I would be more than happy to donate all of my organs to the clown who came up with this bill.
SOURCE
I can't donate because of my hepatitis C but I would be more than happy to donate all of my organs to the clown who came up with this bill.
SOURCE
Jan 19, 10:53 AM EST
Bill would make Coloradans organ donors by default
By KRISTEN WYATT
Associated Press
DENVER (AP) -- Colorado drivers sign up for organ and tissue donation at higher rates than in any other state. But state lawmakers are considering a first-in-the-nation change so that people getting driver's licenses would be presumed organ donors unless they indicate otherwise.
The "presumed consent" system for organ donation is common in Europe and is credited with dramatically raising organ donation rates. (Ya think? - j)
In the U.S., however, similar programs have been defeated by lawmakers in at least three states - Delaware, Illinois and New York - amid ethical fears that "presumed consent" opt-out donation programs seem coercive.
Organ donation advocates hope the program gets a warmer reception in Colorado, where already nearly two-thirds of people carrying driver's licenses or state-issued identification volunteer to be considered as organ or tissue donors. (Key word "volunteer" -- j)
Colorado's proposal, introduced last week, would change the process for renewing driver's licenses and state-issued ID cards so applicants are assumed organ donors unless the applicant initials a statement that he or she doesn't wish to be considered as a possible donor.
Applicants would get a statement that reads, "You are automatically deemed to have consented to being an organ and tissue donor and this designation will appear on your driver's license or identification card."
One of the bill's sponsors, Democratic Rep. Daniel Pabon of Denver, said the change would simply make it easier for people already willing to become organ donors. (We would no longer have to actually speak the one syllable words "yes" or "no". What could be easier than that? -- j)
"This takes a bunch of people who otherwise might donate but just get in the DMV and don't want to stand in line, or they forget, and this makes it easier," said Pabon, whose uncle received a liver transplant after three years on a waiting list in Iowa. (Ah ha! there's the agenda. his uncle had to wait so he wants to up the pool. Also , there is no "line" to stand in to be a donor and when you renew your license you are asked by the person attending to you if you8 wish to be a donor. This is simple made-up bullshit. -- j)
Pabon noted that Coloradans already seem to embrace organ and tissue donation. About 65.6 percent of people with state-issued identifications, or more than 2.9 million people, are volunteer donors, state officials said. Colorado's donor volunteer rate leads the nation, even though the state doesn't offer discounts on state IDs for organ and tissue donors, as some states do.
"This issue is one that's ripe for Colorado," Pabon said of his presumed consent proposal.
Despite Colorado's donation-friendly environment, organ donation advocates say the state still doesn't have enough donors to meet demand.
"After people pass away, there's a way to save nine lives, 10 lives with organ and tissue donations," said Steve Farber, a prominent Denver attorney who received a kidney transplant from his son and co-wrote 2009's "On the List: Fixing America's Failing Organ Transplant System."
Farber founded the American Transplant Foundation and hasn't yet taken a position on Colorado's opt-out proposal. However, even if Colorado raises organ and tissue donations through an opt-out system, there would still be a shortage because medical demand far outpaces supply, he said.
One of the nation's most prominent supporters of opt-out donation programs, Arthur Caplan of the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Bioethics, agreed that waiting lists aren't going away.
"The demand for organs is growing so fast that even if we do this, we're not going to meet the shortage," Caplan said.
He had some advice for Colorado lawmakers supporting the change: Replace the "presumed consent" title on the bill with a better-sounding "default to donation." Caplan says that to American ears, the phrase "presumed consent" sounds too Orwellian. (What is Orwellian is the newspeak phraseology this guy suggests. -- j)
"When you use the word 'presumed' it sounds like you're just going to take the organ, and that doesn't sound good," said Caplan, who last year argued in favor of New York's failed attempt at presumed consent for organ and tissue donation.
---
Online:
Senate Bill 42: http://goo.gl/MlKSw
© 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.