Still incomplete

SouthernN'Proud said:
That's fine. But their contribution to rock history, especially the live performance/stage element, is undeniable.

I don't have to like an artist to appreciate their contributions. I ain't never been called a Neil Young fan, but he deserves to be there.
Click to expand...

When all you have going for you is theatrics and a couple of well known songs, I don't think that qualifies as a great rock band though. Anyone can put on makeup and put pytrotechnics in their shows. It's more gimmick than legend for me. Eiw and Gene Simmons is gross, always has been.

I don't like Neil Young either. Or Bob Dylan - that one drives my husband crazy. I will say though, after seeing that documentary that Marty Scorcese directed on Bob Dylan, I do have a greater appreciation. Maybe because I wasn't introduced to him during the decades he was most popular, I only associate him with his later stuff where I can't understand a word.
 
30+ platinum albums speak otherwise.

I am completely flabbergasted that rational people can claim that Leonard Cohen is bigger in the history of rock and roll than KISS is. Like or dislike the music all you want, that isn't the criteria. Maybe I should look into joining the Leonard Cohen Army.
 
greenfreak said:
When all you have going for you is theatrics and a couple of well known songs, I don't think that qualifies as a great rock band though.
Click to expand...

Yeah. That's all they ever had.

Anyone can put on makeup and put pytrotechnics in their shows. It's more gimmick than legend for me.
Click to expand...

But the thing is, no one DID before them. Until they came along, people sat on stools and strummed anti-war songs.


Eiw and Gene Simmons is gross, always has been.
Click to expand...

You're absolutely right. I completely overlooked that critical criteria. Ugly people don't matter.

Enjoying the new American Idol season?
 
So you don't agree with the inductees, some people wouldn't agree if KISS got inducted. It's a personal opinion...and the people who make the choices have personal opinions just like any other. Not everyone has to share your opinions, and you don't have to agree with theirs...However, that does NOT make their opinions incorrect. Last I checked there isn't a checklist of requirements to be inducted into a hall of fame...a lot of it is how the decisions makers see the people.
 
Leonard Cohen Discography

Songs Of Love And Hate (2007) Remastered $10.09
Songs From A Room (1969) Bonus Tracks; Remastered $10.09
Essential Leonard Cohen (2002) Limited Edition; Remastered $18.95
Best Of Leonard Cohen (1975) $10.09
I'm Your Man (1988) $9.15
Various Positions $7.05
Death Of A Ladies' Man (1977) $9.15
New Skin For The Old Ceremony $9.15
Cohen Live $7.05
Dear Heather (2004) $11.39
Field Commander Cohen: Tour Of 1979 $5.54
Future (1992) $12.45
More Best Of (1997) $10.09
New Skin For The Old Ceremony $5.54
Recent Songs (1979) $9.15
Ten New Songs (2001) $10.09
Click to expand...

3 greatest hits, 2 live albums included




Kiss Discography

20TH Century Masters: The Millennium Collection Vol. 3 (2006) $8.19
20TH Century Masters: The Millennium Collection: The Best Of Kiss (2003) $15.15
20TH Century Masters: The Millennium Collection: The Best Of Kiss Vol. 2 (2004) $8.19
Ace Frehley (1978)
Alive II (1977) Limited Edition; Remastered $17.69
Alive III (1993) $11.99
Alive! (1975) Remastered $17.69
Animalize (1984) Remastered $8.19
Asylum (1985) Remastered $8.19
Carnival Of Souls: The Final Sessions (1997) $5.69
Crazy Nights (1987) Remastered $8.19
Creatures Of The Night (1982) $8.19
Destroyer (1976) Remastered $8.19
Double Platinum (1978) $16.29
Dressed To Kill (1975) Remastered $8.19
Dynasty (1979) $8.19
Gene Simmons (1978)
Gold (2005) Remastered $17.15
Greatest Kiss (1997) $17.05
Hot In The Shade (1989) $8.19
Hotter Than Hell (1974) Remastered $8.09
Kiss (1974) Remastered $8.19
Kiss: The Box Set (Standard) (2001) $58.05
Lick It Up (1983) Remastered $8.19
Love Gun (1977) Remastered $8.19
MTV Unplugged (1996) $13.15
Music From The Elder (1981) Remastered $8.19
Paul Stanley (1978)
Peter Criss (1978)
Revenge (1992) $10.85
Rock And Roll Over (1976) Remastered $8.19
Smashes, Thrashes And Hits (1988) $12.39
Symphony: Alive IV (2003) $21.35
Unmasked (1980) $8.19
Very Best Of Kiss (2002) $10.85
You Wanted The Best, You Got The Best!
Click to expand...

7 greatest hits, 7 live, and 1 boxed set included.

Your Honor, the defense rests.
 
SouthernN'Proud said:
Yeah. That's all they ever had.

But the thing is, no one DID before them. Until they came along, people sat on stools and strummed anti-war songs.

You're absolutely right. I completely overlooked that critical criteria. Ugly people don't matter.

Enjoying the new American Idol season?
Click to expand...

SNP, relax sweets! :hug: I was casually stating how I feel, not looking for a big debate on the impact of KISS. :lol:

I'm telling you what KISS means to me, which is apparently quite a lot less than you. I'm not arguing that ugly people don't matter. That's absurd.

Seriously, I can't even have a casual conversation in the Entertainment forum? Can we lighten it up a bit, please?

Anyway, since you asked, AI kinda sucks this year. They've got a few more weeks to go to pare down to some talent, which is not much. And the judges annoy me more than they ever have. But I have a feeling that your question was sarcastic so I won't go on. :p
 
Alright, Leonard Cohen is debatable. But c'mon MADONNA? Rock isn't that broad.
 
I'm still searching for the words to adequately express my level of pure shock that this discussion is even happening.

Tell ya what though. Since all the catagories are so broad now, I wanna see Motorhead in the Country Hall Of Fame, Cyndi Lauper in an opera, and Marilyn Manson tour with Amy Grant.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top