Professur
Well-Known Member
Nixy .... Tires aren't all that's involved in stopping a car. In fact, a set of tires that are total crap on one car can be just what's wanted on another. I've done it. A car with a stiff suspension will brake better with a tire with a softer sidewall. A car with a soft ride will perform better with a stiffer wall. Then there's tread pattern, number of belts, even tire pressure. You'd be horrified to know just how big a difference one pound of air can make. Then there's the suspension geometry, brake pad material, etc. Not to mention driver ability.
Now, given the dozens of different models that Goodyear makes, the thousands of different combinations of tread, sidewall, and rubber, and the millions of combinations including different cars .... I think you might just be talking out the top of your head. I've had Goodyear rubber on three different cars (at least) and never had a complaint. Michelin on others. Toyo and Bridgestone too.
That's not to say that certain tire combinations don't work. The stock tires from the Mirage were Michelins, and while they were ok in dry weather, in wet or snow, they were awful. Changed them out for another model of Michelins and they were as good as any.
This is why we've now got consumer reports to benefit from. If you pick a car model and tire model ... odds are someone else has already tried it, and if it didn't work ... complained to someone else.
Now, Altron's said that he's replacing with the same model and size, which means that if he's happy with how his car performs now... he'll probably like it still.
Now, given the dozens of different models that Goodyear makes, the thousands of different combinations of tread, sidewall, and rubber, and the millions of combinations including different cars .... I think you might just be talking out the top of your head. I've had Goodyear rubber on three different cars (at least) and never had a complaint. Michelin on others. Toyo and Bridgestone too.
That's not to say that certain tire combinations don't work. The stock tires from the Mirage were Michelins, and while they were ok in dry weather, in wet or snow, they were awful. Changed them out for another model of Michelins and they were as good as any.
This is why we've now got consumer reports to benefit from. If you pick a car model and tire model ... odds are someone else has already tried it, and if it didn't work ... complained to someone else.
Now, Altron's said that he's replacing with the same model and size, which means that if he's happy with how his car performs now... he'll probably like it still.