Based on what he told police, David McMenemy's plan to destroy an abortion clinic worked out much differently in his head from what played out Monday in Davenport, Iowa.
McMenemy, 45, most recently of Rochester Hills admitted dousing the interior of his silver 2004 Saturn with gasoline he had in a Gatorade bottle and plunging the vehicle into a women's health clinic early that morning. And he told police he planned to die in the ensuing fire.
But the clinic whose lobby the native Detroiter drove into -- the Edgerton Women's Health Center -- doesn't perform abortions or even provide referrals for them. And the impact wasn't enough to cause a fire, so McMenemy had to pour more gas on the car.
And once it was ablaze, he scratched his plan to kill himself when he realized it was going to be painful.
No one was injured.
It all left local and federal police wondering whether McMenemy is a calculating criminal who spent weeks scouting the Midwest for abortion clinics to destroy, or nothing more than a suicidal, unemployed amateur criminal.
"Is he just a fruitcake, or is he better connected?" asked Scott County Prosecutor William Davis. "We don't know. We're hoping to get better information on him."
McMenemy is charged with one count of second-degree arson after the fire caused an estimated $200,000 in damage to the building's lobby. He received a court-appointed attorney Wednesday and is scheduled for an arraignment Oct. 5. He is being held without bond.
Iowa authorities and the U.S. Attorney's Office in Davenport asked the FBI and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms to assist in the investigation, though an FBI spokesman said that agency was unlikely to get involved.
According to a probable cause affidavit, McMenemy told police that he drove into the center because he thought it was an abortion clinic. Edgerton president Tom Fedje said that it provides parenting and health services to low-income women and families, but not abortions.
He added that there is a Planned Parenthood that performs abortions in nearby Bettendorf, Iowa.
"Did he go to the wrong site? That's what we're all wondering," Fedje asked. "I have no idea if he got a list of agencies. He simply jumped to the conclusion that we do abortions."
Davis said investigators are checking credit card receipts and other information to determine whether McMenemy might have had contact with others targeting abortion clinics. McMenemy, who is under a suicide watch, is also expected to have a psychiatric evaluation.
A woman who answered the phone at a former residence of McMenemy in Sterling Heights declined to give her name but identified herself as his niece. She said he is a former Marine who has been unemployed for some time, and that his family believed he was depressed.
McMenemy has spent no time in Michigan prisons, according to state Department of Corrections records.
Kathi Di Nicola, a spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood of Iowa, said the organization was aware of Monday's incident.
McMenemy's court-appointed attorney, David Morrison, did not return a call seeking comment. Davis said the decision to hold McMenemy without bond is very unusual in Scott County.
"We think he might be a danger to the community if he's let out," Davis said.